When we talk about box breathing or any breath-holding technique, it’s essential to remember that breath retention inherently engages the sympathetic nervous system. This activation can heighten alertness and stress responses over time, which isn’t necessarily conducive to true somatic release.

1. Shallow Water Blackout Comparison: In shallow water blackout, hyperventilation reduces CO2 levels, delaying the urge to breathe and risking oxygen depletion. Similarly, with intense breath-holding during box breathing or other structured patterns, the body can reach a point of convulsions or involuntary movements as a way to protect itself when oxygen levels drop or CO2 levels surge. This reaction can be the body’s last-resort attempt to regain balance rather than a true release of stored tension.

2. Distinguishing Somatic Release from Protective Responses: Genuine somatic release is about creating a safe environment for the body to release stored physical or emotional tension through parasympathetic activation, promoting deep relaxation and healing. When breath-holding leads to convulsions or extreme physical reactions, it’s likely the body’s protective mechanism kicking in, triggered by the sympathetic response. Instead of releasing tension, it’s reacting to what it perceives as a threat, trying to restore oxygen flow and balance.

3. Convulsions as Sympathetic Activation: Convulsions or intense involuntary movements in response to extended breath-holding aren’t typically somatic releases. They’re the body’s way of overriding the hold to protect itself from a perceived state of suffocation or imbalance. Rather than being a release of stored energy, it’s a sympathetic reaction to potential oxygen deprivation.

4. Your Hypothesis is Valid: Given this understanding, your hypothesis is well-grounded. Breath-holding to the point of convulsions likely isn’t facilitating somatic release but instead triggering a fight-or-flight response. True somatic release should be parasympathetic in nature, characterized by calm, rhythmic breathing that allows the nervous system to reset gently and safely.

More info here

Breath Family Members group

Experience it here

Breathing Hooping Taking Questions

How Conscious Breathing Unlocks Real Weight Loss

This Device Replaces Your Deodorant and Uses No Chemicals at All (Just Energy)

Breath Awarness Breathing Beyond Techniques: One-on-One with The Black Airbender

New Crystal Lenses Cases + Breath Dojo 11

See all posts from theblackairbender